EXPLAINER
Stablecoins explained: what actually backs them, and what happens when it does not
Fiat-backed, crypto-collateralised and algorithmic stablecoins fail in completely different ways. The mechanism is the risk.
Quick answer
Fiat-backed stablecoins hold reserves and depend on the issuer being honest and solvent. Crypto-collateralised ones over-collateralise and depend on liquidations working. Algorithmic ones depend on continued demand and have failed repeatedly.
“Stable” describes an intention, not a property. What determines whether the intention holds is the mechanism.
Fiat-backed
The issuer holds dollars or short-term instruments and issues tokens against them. This works as long as the reserves exist, are liquid, and the issuer honours redemptions. Your risk is entirely the issuer: solvency, honesty and the jurisdiction they operate in.
Read reserve reports carefully. An attestation confirming assets at a point in time is not an audit of the business, and the distinction matters — the same gap covered in our piece on proof of reserves.
Crypto-collateralised
Backed by other crypto, deliberately over-collateralised because the collateral is volatile. Positions liquidate automatically if collateral falls too far. The mechanism is transparent and on-chain, which is a real advantage. It depends on liquidations executing in a falling market, which is exactly when they are hardest.
Algorithmic
No meaningful collateral; the peg is maintained by mint-and-burn incentives. These have failed repeatedly and spectacularly, because the mechanism relies on demand that disappears precisely when it is needed. Treat any variant with strong scepticism regardless of the yield attached.
The practical questions
What backs it, who holds that backing, who can verify it, and what has happened when it was last stressed? A peg that has held during calm conditions has told you very little.
Related reading
- How to evaluate a new coin launch in fifteen minutes — A short checklist for new tokens: supply and unlocks, who is funded, what it does that an existing
- What market cap does not tell you about a cryptocurrency — Market cap is price multiplied by supply. Neither half is as solid as it looks, and the product
- How to read a crypto whitepaper and what to skip — Most whitepapers are marketing with equations. Four sections tell you almost everything; the rest is usually decoration.
Key takeaways
- The backing mechanism determines the failure mode.
- An attestation is not an audit.
- A stablecoin holding its peg has not proved anything until it is stressed.
Risk notice
Cryptocurrency prices are volatile and you can lose the full value of a position. Nothing here is a price prediction or a recommendation to buy or sell. Do your own research.
Frequently asked questions
Are stablecoins safe to hold?
They carry issuer, regulatory and mechanism risk. A fiat-backed stablecoin is a claim on a company, which is a different thing from holding dollars.
What is a depeg?
When the token trades away from its target. Small brief deviations are normal in stressed markets; large or sustained ones indicate the mechanism is failing.